Fundraising Tools and Software     |     28 December 2023

OneCause vs. Givesmart vs. Silent Auction Pro: Features, pricing, reviews, and more

Navigating the world of the most popular fundraising software options

17 minute read

Close up of two people working on laptops comparing notes

Choosing the right software can be quite the task in a world where fundraising events are pivotal for many organizations. The sheer number of options can be overwhelming for those tasked with this decision. Among the numerous choices, OneCause and GiveSmart have emerged as popular solutions, favored by many for their robust features and user-friendly interfaces. Yet, another player in town is making waves - Silent Auction Pro. 

Silent Auction Pro offers an almost identical set of features, like mobile bidding, donor management, and event management, plus a few extra perks, like AI-powered reports, at a more affordable price. That's why Silent Auction Pro has near-perfect reviews on sites like Capterra, Software Advice, and Slashdot. While you might be looking at how OneCause vs. Givesmart compares, it's worth looking at Silent Auction Pro for more robust features at a lower price. Ultimately, you want the fundraising software that works best for your organization. 

Whether you're looking to start your fundraising game or just need to update your fundraising software, look at this comprehensive comparison of OneCause vs. Givesmart vs. Silent Auction Pro. 

An in-depth look at OneCause vs. GiveSmart

OneCause: A closer look at its offerings

OneCause Logo

OneCause has carved out a niche in the fundraising software space and is known for its comprehensive suite of tools designed to facilitate smooth and successful fundraising events. Let's take a look at what makes OneCause a go-to choice for many:

  • Mobile bidding and auction management: OneCause streamlines the auction process with its intuitive mobile bidding system, making it easier for attendees to participate and bid, regardless of location.
  • Peer-to-peer fundraising: This feature amplifies fundraising efforts by allowing supporters to create and share personal fundraising pages, expanding reach and engagement.
  • Event management tools: From ticketing to guest list management, OneCause offers a range of tools to efficiently manage every aspect of fundraising events.
  • Data and analytics: Its robust reporting capabilities allow users to gain insightful data to optimize future fundraising strategies.

GiveSmart: Unpacking its unique features

GiveSmart Logo

GiveSmart has also earned its stripes in the fundraising arena, offering a suite of tools that cater to the dynamic needs of modern fundraisers:

  • User-friendly auction platform: GiveSmart's platform focuses on simplifying the auction process, making it accessible for both organizers and participants.
  • Diverse fundraising options: From silent auctions to galas, GiveSmart provides versatility, allowing organizations to tailor their fundraising approach.
  • Integrated communication tools: With email and text communications tools, staying connected with supporters is a breeze.
  • Real-time reporting: GiveSmart's real-time data tracking empowers organizers with immediate insights into their fundraising progress.

Comparing OneCause vs. GiveSmart

When placed side by side, both OneCause and GiveSmart offer impressive features, but there are a few differences worth considering:

Feature set

While both platforms offer similar core functionalities like auction management and peer-to-peer fundraising, the depth and implementation of these features can vary. OneCause offers more features for event-based fundraising, like ticketing, seating, and registration. GiveSmart leans more toward mobile bidding and online auctions. 

Ease of use

The user experience is a critical factor; here, personal preference plays a big role. Some users may find OneCause's interface more intuitive. Users can access tutorials, videos, and webinars to learn how to use the platform. It also offers a customer success team with 24/7 phone and email support. GiveSmart's streamlined approach is favored by those who want to get right in and get to work. It also offers phone and email support, but only during business hours. 

Customization and flexibility

Each platform offers different levels of customization, which can impact how well the software integrates into an organization's unique workflow. OneCause allows users to customize their campaign pages, emails, and receipts with their branding, logos, and color schemes. You can also integrate this software with other platforms like Salesforce or Mailchimp. GiveSmart is beloved for having less complexity, hassle, and additional fees for integrations. 

Pricing structure of OneCause vs. GiveSmart

OneCause presents a pricing model that aims to cater to various fundraising needs, from smaller organizations to larger, more complex events. GiveSmart's pricing strategy is tailored to provide flexibility and scalability, which is important for organizations with varying fundraising requirements.

Platform Subscription tiers Inclusions and add-ons Transparent pricing
OneCause Different levels of subscription, each scaling up in features and support. Core features such as mobile bidding, event management,and reporting are included in most plans. Advanced features like peer-to-peer fundraising might require a higher-tier subscription or come as an add-on. Straightforward pricing, with minimal hidden costs.
GiveSmart Flexible packages, with more customization options. Some plans are all-inclusive, providing a wide array of features in one package, while others offer a base package with optional add-ons for greater flexibility. Transparent pricing, but requires more direct consultation for precise pricing details.

Real-world feedback from clients and users

OneCause user reviews

Feedback from OneCause users generally highlights several strengths and areas for improvement:

  • Positive aspects: Users often praise OneCause's user-friendly interface and robust support. The platform's comprehensive event management and mobile bidding features are also popular.
  • Areas for improvement: Some users have mentioned wanting more advanced customization options, particularly in reporting and event page design.

GiveSmart user reviews

Reviews of GiveSmart paint a picture of the platform's performance in real-world scenarios:

  • Positive aspects: Clients typically appreciate GiveSmart for its flexibility and the level of customization it allows. The platform's customer service and support team are also commonly applauded.
  • Areas for improvement: On the flip side, there are occasional remarks about the learning curve associated with utilizing the full range of GiveSmart's features.

Comparative Insights

Drawing insights from user reviews of both platforms, it becomes clear that while OneCause excels in user-friendliness and a straightforward approach, GiveSmart stands out for its customization capabilities and adaptable pricing models. The choice between the two often comes down to the specific priorities and preferences of the fundraising organization – whether they value simplicity and ease of use or flexibility and customization.

Introducing Silent Auction Pro: An all-encompassing alternative

Silent Auction Pro Logo

Silent Auction Pro stands out in the busy world of fundraising software, offering a straightforward and effective way to handle auctions, events, and more; it all started with Jim, the founder, who used his volunteering experience to build something that genuinely addresses the challenges of running fundraisers. This platform goes beyond managing auctions; it helps make the entire process smoother and more enjoyable for everyone involved.

With a team that's walked in the shoes of its users, Silent Auction Pro knows exactly what makes a fundraising event tick. From school fundraisers to big charity galas, it's designed to be easy to use, versatile, and affordable, ensuring your event runs without a hitch. It's the kind of tool that lets you focus on what's important – your cause and community – while it takes care of the details.

Key features and advantages

Silent Auction Pro emerges as a strong contender in the fundraising software arena, bringing with it a suite of features designed to simplify and improve the fundraising experience. Key features and advantages include the following:

  • Versatile auction software: Whether it's an online/mobile auction, live event, or a mix of both, the platform covers it all, with offerings like online auction catalogs, support for live auctions, and creative fundraising games.
  • Effortless event management: Beyond auctions, the software excels in donor tracking, creating custom landing pages, and generating detailed reports. It's designed to manage your event from start to finish, ensuring nothing slips through the cracks.
  • Streamlined ticketing and seating: Building your event's ticketing page is a breeze, with options for admission, raffle tickets, sponsorships, and more. The drag-and-drop seating management tool further uncomplicates organizing your event.
  • Powerful marketing and communication tools: Keep your guests informed and engaged with customized emails, texts, and scheduled messages, complete with detailed reporting on their effectiveness.
  • Flexible donation options: The platform supports various donation methods, including text-to-give, giving campaigns, and recurring donations, making it easy for supporters to contribute in a way that suits them.
  • Innovative paddle raise feature: Enhance your paddle raises with real-time tracking, a live thermometer for goal progress, and a virtual confetti drop to celebrate hitting targets.
  • AI-driven donor insights: The new AI report offers an in-depth look into your donor base, providing valuable data on demographics, wealth status, and interests, helping you tailor your fundraising strategy effectively.

Silent Auction Pro is about creating an environment where every aspect of your fundraising event, from ticket sales to donor engagement, is optimized for success. Whether your event is in-person, virtual, or hybrid, this software ensures a smooth, engaging experience for organizers and participants alike.

Usability and interface

In terms of usability and interface, Silent Auction Pro strikes a balance between functionality and user-friendliness:

  • User-friendly design: The platform is designed with the end-user in mind, ensuring that navigating various features is intuitive and hassle-free.
  • Customizable interfaces: Understanding the importance of brand consistency, Silent Auction Pro allows organizations to tailor the look and feel of their event pages and communications.
  • Dedicated help and support services: Silent Auction Pro has extended support hours (9:00 am Eastern to 7:00 pm Pacific on weekdays and 12:00 pm Eastern to 5:00 pm Pacific on weekends) plus free support on the night of your event, regardless of what time it takes place. 
  • Comprehensive help videos: On-demand videos and tutorials covering everything from using various aspects of the software to best practices for your events. 
  • Extensive help center: Find checklists, quick reference cards, and more, offering practical advice on every aspect of planning and executing your fundraising event. 

Why Silent Auction Pro stands out

Silent Auction Pro distinguishes itself from OneCause and GiveSmart in several ways:

  • Ease of use for volunteers: Recognizing that many users are volunteers, the platform is built to be straightforward to learn, reducing the training time required.
  • Flexibility in event types: Silent Auction Pro supports various events, from traditional in-person events to fully virtual or hybrid formats.
  • Customer-centric support: With a strong focus on support, Silent Auction Pro ensures users have access to the assistance they need when they need it.

Understanding Silent Auction Pro's pricing and value

When it comes to pricing, Silent Auction Pro offers a model that is transparent and tailored to fit various event sizes and types:

  • Transparent and scalable pricing: The platform provides clear pricing structures that scale according to the features required and the size of the event.
  • No hidden fees: One of the key aspects of Silent Auction Pro's pricing model is its commitment to transparency, with no hidden costs to catch organizations off-guard.
  • Increased engagement and revenue: By enhancing the bidding experience and making event management more efficient, Silent Auction Pro helps increase participant engagement, leading to higher fundraising revenues.
  • Time and resource savings: The platform's ease of use and comprehensive features mean less time and fewer resources are needed for event setup and management, translating to organization cost savings.

Customer Experiences with Silent Auction Pro

Gathering insights from those who have used Silent Auction Pro provides a window into its effectiveness and appeal:

  • High satisfaction rates: Users consistently report satisfaction with Silent Auction Pro, particularly praising its user-friendly interface and efficient customer support.
  • Positive impact on fundraising results: Many testimonials highlight Silent Auction Pro's positive impact on their fundraising efforts, with notable increases in event participation and revenue.

OneCause vs. GiveSmart vs. Silent Auction Pro: Features, Pricing, and User Satisfaction

Feature Comparison Table

Feature OneCause GiveSmart Silent Auction Pro
Mobile Bidding Yes Yes Yes
Event Management Comprehensive Flexible All-in-one
User Interface User-friendly Minimalistic & clean Intuitive & customizable
Communication Tools Advanced Integrated Robust & customizable
Reporting and Analytics Extensive Real-time Advanced & comprehensive
Pricing Flexibility Tiered subscriptions Customizable packages Transparent & scalable
Customer Support Strong High Exceptional

Pricing and Value Comparison

Platform Pricing Structure Ideal for
OneCause Straightforward, tiered pricing Organizations with predictable needs
GiveSmart Customizable pricing Those needing specific features and willing to pay for them
Silent Auction Pro Transparent and scalable pricing A range of event sizes and types, offering great value

User Satisfaction and Reviews

Platform User satisfaction insights
OneCause Appreciated for ease of use and comprehensive features; some desire more customization
GiveSmart Praised for flexibility and customer service; has a steeper learning curve
Silent Auction Pro High marks for user-friendly approach, excellent support, and effective fundraising enhancement

Finding the right fit: OneCause vs. SmartGive vs. Silent Auction Pro

Navigating the world of fundraising software can be a complex journey. The right platform choice ultimately hinges on your organization's specific requirements and goals. Whether it's the simplicity and comprehensive nature of OneCause, the customizable flexibility of GiveSmart, or the user-centric, endless features and cost-effective approach of Silent Auction Pro, each platform has something distinct.

Discover More About Silent Auction Pro

A tablet, laptop screen, and mobile phone
								displaying the Silent Auction Pro software

If Silent Auction Pro has piqued your interest, it's time to dive deeper into what it can offer. Explore its features, understand its pricing model, and read more testimonials to see how it could fit into your fundraising strategy. Request a demo to see how they can help you plan/manage events, build a stronger community, and take your fundraising efforts to new heights. 

Remember, choosing the right fundraising software is a crucial decision that can significantly impact the success of your events. Take the time to assess your options carefully and consider Silent Auction Pro as a solution that combines efficiency, ease of use, and value all in one package.

profile picture
Becca Wallace   | Product Director

Getting a grass roots upbringing in charity events and auctions, Becca's background in volunteering helps her understand the needs of everyday and seasoned professional event planners alike. Her passion for using technology to make things easier drives her UI | UX design aesthetic to continually refine Silent Auction Pro. With 15 years of event planning experience and almost 10 years of software and user expereince design behind her, Becca works tirelessly to advance Silent Auction Pro to be simple, sophisticated and user-friendly.

Back to top